Second time staying here. Would stay again.
When you factor in reasonable rates and location, it’s a great place to stay in Cruz Bay and hard to beat. Only a few minute walk to taxi stand and downtown bars/restaurants, so no need to rent a vehicle while staying here. I’d take taxi to beaches each day and not have to worry about finding parking.
As others have said, rooms are simple, but clean and comfortable. Restaurant and small bar on site, and Provisions next door and Dolphin Market around corner. Really good breakfast, and dinner was great when I’ve had it here before. Fridge in room. Beach chairs and coolers provided for day at beach and bar will provide ice for cooler. Remember - no glass permitted on beaches, so buy cans if you plan to take some brews to beach. Good selection of adult beverages at nearby Dolphin Market.
Only “drawback” is there are several roosters in close proximity who enjoy practicing their vocals come 4:00am or so, but that’s the same as in many other places I’ve stayed in USVI’s and BVI’s! Free entertainment is how I see it! :)