Cheap Flights to Shelter Island

  • Plan, book, fly with confidence
  • trending down icon
    Be in the know
    Get alerts if flight prices drop or rise*
  • bex rewards loyalty icon
    Book smarter
    Save up to 35% on select hotels after you book a flight*
  • payments icon
    Earn twice
    Earn your airline miles on top of our rewards
    Sign in

Cheap Tickets to Shelter Island

These prices were available within the past 7 days. Prices quoted are per person, return, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

United
Wed., 5 Feb. - Sat., 19 Apr.
MEL
Tullamarine
LGA
LaGuardia
AU$1,545 Return, found 6 days ago
AU$1,545
Return
found 6 days ago
Select United flight, departing Wed., 5 Feb. from Tullamarine to LaGuardia, returning Sat., 19 Apr., priced at AU$1,545 found 6 days ago
United
Wed., 5 Feb. - Thu., 20 Feb.
MEL
Tullamarine
EWR
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
AU$1,545 Return, found 6 days ago
AU$1,545
Return
found 6 days ago
Select United flight, departing Wed., 5 Feb. from Tullamarine to Newark Liberty Intl. Airport, returning Thu., 20 Feb., priced at AU$1,545 found 6 days ago
Jetstar
Sat., 1 Feb. - Sun., 9 Feb.
AVV
Avalon
LGA
LaGuardia
AU$1,570 Return, found 3 days ago
AU$1,570
Return
found 3 days ago
Select Jetstar flight, departing Sat., 1 Feb. from Avalon to LaGuardia, returning Sun., 9 Feb., priced at AU$1,570 found 3 days ago
Jetstar
Fri., 31 Jan. - Mon., 10 Feb.
MEL
Tullamarine
JFK
John F. Kennedy Intl.
AU$1,588 Return, found 5 hours ago
AU$1,588
Return
found 5 hours ago
Select Jetstar flight, departing Fri., 31 Jan. from Tullamarine to John F. Kennedy Intl., returning Mon., 10 Feb., priced at AU$1,588 found 5 hours ago
Jetstar
Mon., 10 Mar. - Sun., 23 Mar.
AVV
Avalon
JFK
John F. Kennedy Intl.
AU$1,614 Return, found 1 day ago
AU$1,614
Return
found 1 day ago
Select Jetstar flight, departing Mon., 10 Mar. from Avalon to John F. Kennedy Intl., returning Sun., 23 Mar., priced at AU$1,614 found 1 day ago
Beautiful view of the beach with palm trees

Black Friday: Members save 30%+

Members save 30%+ on selected hotels until 4 Dec (property time) with our Black Friday deals. Stay by 15 Dec 2025.
Unlock Black Friday deals

Shelter Island Flights

Have the time of your life in Shelter Island

Flying to Shelter Island is now easier than ever when you use Expedia to book your trip. We’ve got an extensive catalogue of Shelter Island flight deals, giving you the greatest number of options to choose from. Whether you prefer to fly on weekdays or weekends, in the morning or at night, a quick search on Expedia.com.au will help you find cheap tickets to Shelter Island in seconds. We even make it simple for you to stick with a certain airline if you’re trying to rack up frequent flyer points.

Tips for flying and packing light

If it’s been a while since you’ve travelled, you might be due for a refresher when it comes to flying. That’s where our helpful blog, Out There Starts Here, comes in. Wondering whether to pack for fine dining or more casual eats? Or whether you really need to bring a jacket? Written by seasoned travel experts, the articles on our blog provide you with the latest details about certain destinations, so you know just what to expect. Check out some of our recent articles for the smartest ways to see the sights.

Fly for less when you bundle airfare and accommodation

Our already low airfares are even more affordable when you bundle your flights with a stay at one of the hotels in Shelter Island. By booking all of your travel plans with us, you’ll save time and money, and enjoy the convenience of having all of your arrangements in one place.

Get the power of planning in the palm of your hand

Booking your trip to Shelter Island, New York has never been easier than when you use our mobile app to plan your dream getaway. The Expedia App is available on both Android and iOS, allowing you to reserve flights and hotels at any time of day, no matter what kind of phone you use. You’ll also get exclusive offers, receive flight updates, and can earn extra points. Wherever you are, the Expedia App helps you get where you want to be.

Join the Expedia Rewards Program

If you enjoy the finer things in life, sign up for our rewards program to receive exclusive benefits when you book with us. Expedia Rewards opens the door to member-only deals, +VIP Access hotel benefits, and earning Expedia Rewards points, that you can redeem your way. You’ll also get access to Unreal Deals that could save you the price of a plane ticket to Shelter Island when bundled with your accommodation.

What are you waiting for?

Expedia.com.au helps you find cheap flights to Shelter Island AU$1,545. So why wait another second to begin planning your trip? Start your search right now, and you could be boarding the next Shelter Island-bound flight. Bon voyage!

Frequently asked questions

What is the name of Shelter Island's airport?
If you’re travelling by air, you won’t have to think too long and hard about which airport to choose. Shelter Island has just one – MacArthur Airport (ISP).
How many airlines fly to Shelter Island?
There are 78 airlines that fly to Shelter Island from 222 worldwide airports.
Which airlines fly to Shelter Island?
American Airlines and Delta Air Lines are some of the most popular airlines that offer flights to Shelter Island. Travelers often use Washington as a departure point with American Airlines operating the most flights on this route.
How many nonstop flights are there to Shelter Island?
With 11 584 nonstop flights running every week, you’ll be hitting the tarmac in Shelter Island before you can ask, “Are we there yet?”
Where are the most popular flights to Shelter Island departing from?
Travellers frequently depart from Toronto, Boston and Chicago airports when heading to Shelter Island.
How long is the flight to Shelter Island Airport?
If it’s Washington you’re departing, you’ll be midair for around 1 hour and 22 minutes before you arrive in Shelter Island. Terminal to terminal from Chicago takes about 2 hours and 10 minutes and from Boston, the flight time is 1 hour and 25 minutes.
How to book the cheapest flight to Shelter Island?
Don’t leave locking in your flight to Shelter Island until the last possible moment. That’s one move seasoned jet-setters use to get the best deals. Booking ahead means more options and cheaper flights. Another fantastic way to score a bargain is to research all options. If where you’re headed has multiple airports, don’t forget to look into the cost of flying into a less busy terminal. Last but not least, be prepared to lock in your seat quickly if you find an irresistible price. It might not be available for too long! With a bit of knowledge and a little luck, the ideal airfare can be yours.
How to survive the flight to Shelter Island?
We’ve pulled together all the info you need to make your flight a stress-free experience. Follow our tips and tricks and you’ll be zooming through airport security and enjoying Shelter Island in no time at all.What to pack in your hand luggage:

  • Flying can be a cruisy experience if you take the right stuff. First of all you’ll need toiletry items, such as lip balm and hand cream, a fresh set of clothes and a magazine or two. Next, find a spot in your carry-on bag for your laptop, a charger, any medications and maybe a cosy neck pillow as well. Last, but definitely not least, be sure to take your passport, travel documents and some money.

Do not pack the following items in your hand luggage:

  • Pack all your full-sized bottles of shampoo and hairspray in your checked luggage. Any liquids or gels in your carry-on bag larger than 3.4 ounces (100 milliliters) will be confiscated by authorities. Sharp or pointed objects, like your pocket knife, and dangerous products which are flammable or explosive, such as flares, chemicals agents and fireworks, are also prohibited.

What to wear on a flight:

  • The goal here is to make yourself as comfortable as possible. Layer up with loose, breathable clothing and take a cardigan just in case you get chilly. Go for a pair of flat, slightly roomy shoes as your feet may swell a little during the flight. Leave the stilettos and hiking boots in your checked baggage.
  • It’s likely you’ve heard about DVT (deep vein thrombosis), a blood clotting condition caused by long periods of inactivity. There are numerous ways to lower your risk. Wear a pair of compression socks or tights, drink plenty of water and remember to keep your legs and feet moving. Do a few laps of the cabin or try out some simple stretches in your seat.

How to get through airport security fast when flying to Shelter Island?
Being prepared before your flight will make your trip to Shelter Island easy and painless. Below are some handy tips and tricks for a swift journey past security:

  • Be sure to keep your ID and travel documents easily accessible. They’re the first things you’ll be asked to present to airport security.
  • Your jacket, belt, keys and other small items, like your headphones, will need to go on a tray through the X-ray machine. Make your life easier by removing them as it gets closer to your turn.
  • All your electronics, including your laptop and phone, will also need to be scanned separately.
  • Want to bring along your favourite hand cream? As long as it’s in a container no larger than 3.4 ounces (100 milliliters) and it’s stored in a zip-close bag, it’s fine to bring with you in your carry-on luggage.
  • Slip-on shoes are a great footwear choice as you’re less likely to be asked to remove them when going through security. Safety boots and heavier-style shoes are usually subjected to additional screening.
  • Take all prohibited items out of your carry-on bag. If you have any sharp objects like a pocket knife or tools, put them in your checked baggage. They won’t be allowed in the cabin.

Flights to Shelter Island information
Destination airport
LaGuardia
Destination airport IATA code
LGA
Destination city name
New York
Return price
AU$1,326

Trending flights to Shelter Island

These prices were available within the past 7 days. Prices quoted are per person, return, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

Philippine Airlines
Thu., 2 Oct. - Sun., 19 Oct.
SYD
Kingsford Smith Intl.
JFK
John F. Kennedy Intl.
AU$1,735 Return, found 3 hours ago
AU$1,735
Return
found 3 hours ago
Select Philippine Airlines flight, departing Thu., 2 Oct. from Kingsford Smith Intl. to John F. Kennedy Intl., returning Sun., 19 Oct., priced at AU$1,735 found 3 hours ago
*Available to Expedia members.