Search Sheffield Island Guest Houses

"I loved how friendly the staff was during the stay and all the features that came with the suite that we stayed in. It was like a small apartment! I also loved that they offered “clean” and “natural” foods as part of their breakfast. I would definitely recommend them to anyone and when we come again, I know where we will be staying! "

"Very close to beach. Nice size room, had view of ocean! "

"We love this hotel :)!"

"The room was spacious and comfortable. The breakfast offers a good variety of foods. The pool area was relaxing, but the pool could have been a bit cleaner."

"Loved our view of the beach. Very quiet and relaxing. Staff was nice and accommodating. Restaurant right next door was also great"

"We had a great stay. We’ve been here before and love the relaxed vibe. Last year the restaurant wasn’t open yet, and what a great addition to the property! All of the staff at the restaurant were kind and accommodating. We are already planning our return for this peaceful little area again."

"Room was nice and clean, bed very comfortable. Loved the pool area with bar."

"The hotel manager got a coffee for me out of their Starbucks after they were closed for the day. Nice guy!"

"Great staff (Hi Lori and others working 7/31-8/3/25!), great breakfast (Hi kitchen staff!), great accommodations! We hated to leave, wish we were still there. All the best to you guys!"