Search Windley Key hotels

"Staff was great, pool area was beautiful. Great Food and drink options. Very relaxing, did not need to leave the resort. Shout out to Matt the bartender who was amazing!"

"My son and his new wife had an amazing time on their honeymoon! They said everything was top notch and have gone on & on about what an amazing time they had! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️"

"Staff was extremely accommodating, Property is stunning with numerous activities. "

"Excelent"

"Amara Cay is absolutely beautiful. The staff is friendly and accommodating. From the welcoming drink to checkout was perfect. Some of the best food and cocktails I’ve had at a resort. Shuttle service will take you wherever you want to go outside the resort. "

"We have been frequent customers. We like the place. "

"We loved the area. We were not impressed with beach options "

"Our stay was short sadly, only 2 nights, but we would gladly stay here again. We had a beautiful view of the ocean from our room and the room itself was clean and comfortable. The hotel offers complimentary water activities and on Saturday morning held a beach yoga class, which was lovely. You can walk to several restaurants easily and there is a free cab service offered by the city for anywhere else locally. I recommend staying here. Our only regret was not being able to stay longer!"

"Everything was very nice. The room was very clean and comfortable. It was very close to really nice restaurants and there’s plenty of shopping. The office staff was super friendly and very nice. I would highly recommend!!"