Highgate Independent in Randall's Island from AU$268

"Great "

"I liked the property a lot! Convenience store right across the street, fast food options within 5 minutes walk. Def staying here again!"

"We came to the city for my daughters 11th birthday, The hotel itself was perfect location for us (walkable to lots) - the rooms were clean, the check in was seamless, and we were able to store our bags while walking around the city (before check in and after check out) which was awesome. But what really made it special was the attendant who checked us in (her name was Dominique) was an absolute gem, made my daughter a little birthday present, She gave us a suggestion of seeing the Statue of Liberty at sunset (which we took her advice and it was incredible). My daughter wouldn't stop talking about how sweet she thought this woman was - she said "I think that's the nicest lady in New York" It really means a lot to me she made my daughters birthday extra special, we wanted to find her to tell her thank you as we were checking out but couldn't find her, so girl if you see this, THANK YOU SO MUCH!"

"Easy access from Penn station "

"The hotel is dilapidated and bathroom was not clean. The bed was comfortable. "

"Place so so nice and convenient to subways. Staff was pleasant! "

"Beautiful Vintage Hotel! Stand were wonderfully helpful and accommodating. Bed was Very comfortable and we didn’t hear a sound at night! (You do hear the great band in the restaurant before 10pm but it’s all good! ) Free and Low cost breakfast/ brunch options are wonderful and make it easy to start your day. Walking distance to Broadway theatres, Times Square, Subway Station, great restaurants— we will return for future trips! "

"From check-in to check-out, everything was wonderful. Staff was great, room was very nice, clean and comfortable. Subway station is located at the end of the block (so convenient), restaurant on-site and room service available. The only downside is the parking situation - we tried the parking garage the hotel staff member suggested and it was full - proceeded to another garage in the vicinity....it was full. Those were both a few blocks away - be prepared to search for parking upon arrival and possibly walking a long distance with your luggage. Just a tip, if you are coming with vehicle. Everything was great - just the parking isn't easy."

"Amazing location . Close to Times Square and all of the major subways and buses. The room is a little small but good shower and comfortable bed. Couldn’t get the tv to work but I had my laptop "