Highgate Independent in Coney Island from AU$297

"It’s amazing. Perfect service great location with a subway stop super close and a TKTS booth for half price tickets around the corner. PJ’s restaurant downstairs is legendary. We had lobster rolls. They let us store bags after we checked out. It’s perfect in every way."

"They upgraded our room for free to make things more convenient. Clean and great location "

"Let me start with the only downside about the property - the rooms are on the smaller side (ots an older building - thats just how they were made), but the fact that they manage to fit 2 queen beds in the room more than makes up for it. Now for the many positives - excellency location - just steps away from Times Square and minutes from any theater we attended. Beautiful art-deco style added to the overall ambiance, and the building is very well staffed and maintained. I would happily stay here again."

"Great hotel! "

"Very clean"

"Really loved this hotel!!!"

"I booked this hotel for a quick trip to the city and I was not disappointed! I read others reviews about the bathrooms, the long elevator waits, the rooms being small? We had the standard 1 King Bed room and it was HUGE for being a NYC hotel room? There was a hallway like area with the closest and the bathroom to your right when you walked in and it was huge! It was so roomy! I really recommend staying here! Ignore the reviews of everyone that has problems with minor hotel flaws. Maybe I just got lucky on room size, but when you stay in NYC, you should automatically assume the room is gonna be smaller"

"Great stay "

"Convenient. Check-in was smooth. Staff helpful with dinner reservations "